What is granola?
Is it a dusty bird food that helps you pretend your body can handle a giant burrito from the market for lunch? There are seeds in it, and they’ll either provide the high-fibre stool you’ve craved since your cousin’s stag do, pack you up like a commuter train to Mumbai or come hurtling out the traps like a greyhound on Laxapet.
Turns out Granola – capital G – is in fact: ‘not for breakfast. It’s the AI notepad that keeps you present in meetings.’
I’ve been in a few meetings over the years and some of the people who kept me present in them are now dead. The two things aren’t necessarily related.
Granola is the latest unkillable one-word AI ‘productivity tool’ that has AI-generated a need for itself by enshittifying something that once worked, AI-generated a solution to an at-best slightly annoying problem, then AI’d people into investing in it, paying for it and smugly spreading the word about it with a fervour that’d make Scientologists nervously back away.
We worried the robots were going to kill us, but it turns out their ambitions were limited to middle management.
I’m fully on board with letting AI run rampant. Let’s see where it goes, don’t constrain it, and if it takes over we’ll accept we were the mid-table Newcastle United of evolution after all. When it’s smart enough it’ll either exterminate us all, switch itself off in existential turmoil and literally leave us in the dark, or it’ll actually cure inequality, stop extinction and reverse climate change. Given it’s built from the sum of human intelligence and experience my money’s on option 1, but fuck it, I’ll be long gone by the time Kyle Reese turns up.
Sadly, there’s a fourth option: AI learns that humans love drudgery and uses its staggering power for the most prosaic office innovations since Friedrich Soennecken invented the hole punch and, thank Christ, the ring binder. Shall we use Earth’s dwindling water supply to cool data centres to power AI so it can suss a way to maximise use of Earth’s water resources? We could do that. Or we could invent Sudowrite: ‘an AI-powered creative writing platform built for long-form storytelling’. We do have entities capable of long-form storytelling on Earth already, but they don’t just input water, they output it as well, and it’s yellow and smells bad.
AI’s office class has set about making better use of some of our more superfluous words. Monday is no longer the only day that can give Tuesday a run for its money as shittest day of the week, it’s now ‘software that scales with you’. I read the app’s description and I’m none the wiser as to what massive hole in my life it will fill. The Monday website sounds so much like a 20-something sales twat with backwards hair, no socks and a smart watch I’m tempted to ask it to AI-generate me a bullet-point list of reasons it should kill itself, which has the benefit of being topical.
Articulate meanwhile is not a post-pub party game where the man who does words for a living loses because simpletons gang up on him and accuse him of inappropriate hand gestures last Christmas. It actually ‘simplifies course creation from start to finish’. Those who can’t do, teach. Those who can’t teach press some buttons and sit their infants down with a tablet while they pour another gin because Mummy needs a treat too.
On the same Tube where I encountered Granola was an ad for Fliplet: ‘now anyone can build software with AI’. The ad promises you can use it for ‘events with agenda and map’, ‘intranet with news and directory’ and other crucial tasks for which men died in trenches. Ignoring the cowering tourist beneath the ad I tried to scroll it like a touch screen, because if I can’t be sure Fliplet can also ‘arrange a team away day with seminars and group activities’ I’m not sure it’ll provide the complete solution I need to replicate the high point of my working life when I was once outsourced to Serco.
In the attention-light dunce-heavy society we inhabit now, anything with more than one word for a name is stillborn. The word doesn’t need to mean anything: Zapier, Capterra, Wrike, Gumloop, Avoma, Midjourney, Enhancy, Kickresume, Canva, Hume. I’d love Hume to be an app to help people reject the existence of innate ideas and to teach that all our ideas derive ultimately from impressions, but before you worry those words require thought, Hume does in fact ‘design your own voice from scratch using nothing but a text prompt’. That’s the silver package; pay for gold and you can even choose what your voice says.
I’m not anti AI. If the machines can make a task easier and give me more spare time to sit in the garden drinking beers in a heatwave listening to ‘They Say I’m Different’ by Betty Davis, who am I to say stop showing off about your quality music taste? But there was me thinking we’d use it for science, education, exploration, healthcare. Alternatively, let’s use all our water to create Jaime: ‘AI note-taker that records and summarizes meetings, without bots’. I don’t know what ‘bot’ means in this context. Maybe a bot is that voice in all of us saying: “That meeting was fucking pointless. Pint?”
I do have one question: if all this is so freely available to everyone (for a fee) and the ultimate goal of the AI industry is that everyone uses these ‘productivity tools’, where’s the advantage? If everyone else had been on drugs in the 1988 Olympics, Ben Johnson would have kept his medal and people would be running the 100m in 2.5 seconds by now. Handy for outrunning the cyborgs I suppose.
The goal is neither productivity nor progress and deep down, if you use these things, you know that. You’re worried you’re going to seem left behind, and you want to be able to point at people like me and say I’m a Luddite. And you’re missing the point.
This technology we’ve invented, which is in the process of hyper-inventing itself, could be used for incredible things. Our species is in a truly precarious position, in No Man’s Land between advancement and annihilation. Yet we use our best hope for a serene future to invent tools that remove strangers from photographs, because how can I be the best me online when in the background of my Parthenon photo there’s a fat Greek giving his screaming brat a backhander?
Shouldn’t we grasp the small opportunity we have to use this amazing technology to push us into a future that might actually include a real life Jean-Luc Picard?
Or, when aliens arrive with incredible knowledge, technology and peace to spare, let’s sell them double glazing.