There’s been a murder.
And then another murder. The corpses are piling up. Funerals where widows meet mistresses, wakes where rival gangs solemnly set aside their shotguns for an hour and everywhere you go an ancient jakey muttering darkly that “there’s been a curse on this family for a hundred years”. People in black pull grim faces and vow revenge; screw the cops, we’ll sort this out “in house”.
Meanwhile, we’re finding out whether Detective Inspector Aoife Regan can patch things up with her girlfriend after a row about washing up liquid.
She’s a real cunt, this Regan. I’m not joking and nor were the writers of Borderline when they pitched the following: two detectives either side of the Irish border must work together for 15 minutes of a two-hour show to solve an almost incidental murder, spending the rest of the show (a) obsessed with whether a furniture salesman shot DCI Philip Boyd’s dad three decades ago, and (b) wondering how anyone can resist the urge to punch Aoife Regan in the face for her stunning disrespect of her bosses and colleagues, the vicar, the milkman, passing schoolchildren and an utterly blameless woman who woke up beside her one regrettable morning.
Murder has become a side issue in the never-ending stream of shows that truly believe we give the slightest fuck about the private lives of fictional detectives. Their marriage troubles, how they’ve missed yet another parents’ evening, how their own parents died in a car crash and that’s what makes them such a maverick, their missing sibling who ran away, or were they kidnapped? Every last area of a detective’s life is dissected in eight or nine scenes, while the dissection of the corpse itself is tossed off in one identikit vignette of a white coated eccentric grinding inexorably to the sentence “I think the motive is more your purview than mine, don’t you, detectives?”
Who exactly do TV executives think cares about this shit? Are there focus groups moaning that the murder allegedly central to the remake of Lynley is getting in the way of DS Barbara Havers finding out exactly why posh boy DI Tommy Lynley has moved to Norfolk? She interrogates her boss with a degree of petulance the real life women going through Hendon College are unlikely to thank her for. I’ve only seen one episode but I’m sure we’ll soon find out that she once had an abusive THERE’S BEEN A FUCKING MURDER BARBARA.
Shouldn’t we at least witness the detective solve a crime or two before we start worrying about exactly how they can afford their dad’s care home bills and all the thrilling implications of corruption that go with it? Nick a few psychos and I’ll start giving a shit. Shetland has been going for years and I can confirm I’ll be sad when DC Sandy Wilson is eventually found floating face down just off Twatt. We didn’t find out much about Vera, but it brought a tear to the eye when she realised the good people of Northumberland would never stop drowning and strangling each other and strolled off down the beach to, I presume, throw herself off Bamburgh Castle just after the cameras stopped rolling.
But if one side of the coin shows a mischievous Andy Dalziel, the other is emblazoned with the gimlet eyes of Commissioner Selwyn Patterson. It’s been tragic to watch the protracted descent of the Paradise franchise. It began as Cat from Red Dwarf trying to do as little work as possible while a parachuted-in white man solved murders the natives apparently could not, because racial stereotypes matter little when there’s sunshine and rum.
There’s now a Paradise universe almost fully devoted to the lives of the dim-until-lightbulb constabulary in various jurisdictions. On the original show the drama now centres around DI Mervin Wilson discovering he has a brother who one suspects will come to disappoint Mervin in some prosaic way. This despite the consistent number of blunt-force traumas still happening on Saint Marie, where we must at this point assume ‘Catherine’ will turn out to be some kind of 21st century Elizabeth Bathory.
Apparently we became so entranced by Kris Marshal as DI Humphrey Goodman that we now have him in the UK-based Beyond Paradise, in which our chief concern is the length to which the detective will go to apologise for his wife having been required to have an affair with a Spurs fan while Humphrey was “swanning around Saint Marie”. There’s both a duck and a mother in law on the narrow boat they live on. One constable has some sort of intellectual disability but can ride a bicycle very quickly. I don’t want to think about the Australian spin-off Return to Paradise, I merely hope sharks eat everyone involved in it.
Other shows won’t just die. There’s a brand new serial killer in Brighton in literally every episode of Grace, though how anyone expects DS Glenn Branson to prioritise that when he has to take his son to football practice I just don’t know. DSupt Roy Grace’s wife who’d faked her own death has reappeared to reclaim their son, which gets more screen time than a man sitting calmly throwing toddlers off the pier.
And it’s even better if a detective has quirks. The lead character of Annika regularly breaks the fourth wall to talk to us about her troubled daughter and it’s truly great TV. Professor T wears clean-freak white gloves that take up a surprising amount of each episode. In Ridley, our hero co-owns a bar and plays jazz in it, the ideal soundtrack to the death of the genre.
It hasn’t always been this way. Jack Frost’s wife was no more likely to turn up on screen than Arthur Daley’s ‘er indoors, though to be fair she did die in the first episode. The various Barnabys of Midsomer Murders provide the comic foil that bookends episodes otherwise entirely devoted to the dreadful fury of the genocidal geriatrics of the British countryside. If you’re in any doubt about the right way to do it, it wasn’t until the 32nd episode of 33 that we found out Inspector Morse’s first name, for fuck’s sake.
Morse’s sidekick got a spin-off of course, though it’s now mostly remembered for the subsequent mental implosion of poor Sergeant Hathaway as Rose Tyler slowly turned the weans against him. Nevertheless in Lewis the hit-and-run killing of DI Robbie Lewis’s wife was mentioned solely to explain his newfound grumpiness, solved in one single episode and barely referenced again. A couple of episodes later he was happily up the blonde pathologist.
What I wouldn’t give for a swift backstory wrap-up these days, which brings me to Cooper & Fry. It’s Channel 5 so, yeah, my bad. But every episode is 30% who shot DC Ben Cooper’s dad five years ago, 25% how DC Diane Fry scarpered from Leeds to rural Derbyshire to escape her stalker (also a cop, and her boss, of course), 20% Cooper’s mum banging on about local legends and ‘the cards’, 5% the crime scene officer saying they can’t give a time of death until they get the body back to the lab and the rest a range of extras begging the police to at least pay lip service to the decapitation of a local teenager found trussed up like a chicken with a Celtic rune up his arse.
If I must be told about the detectives’ lives, make it count. Make it funny (Ludwig). Give the character depth (Dalgleish). Cheat and give us more on a character we already love (Endeavour). Don’t subject us to more of whatever sadistic Bertha shat out Death Valley, where wacky DS Janie Mallowan acts like a testy 10 year old for 45 minutes and Timothy Spall looks like he’s on hunger strike.
It’s my final tossed-off-detective-shite straw and I’m tapping out. I accidentally watched 10 minutes of Eastenders this week and Cindy’s back, plotting to kill a teenager or something. Maybe I’ll switch to soaps, because if I’m forced to watch another detective sadly eyeing divorce papers, next time there’s a murder I’ll be praying it’s mine.
Fuxake mate, did Amazon finally sus your dodgy Firestick?