I love a darkly comic novel, so when I heard of an award-nominated book about an innocent man unwittingly pulled into the villainous world of his recently deceased uncle, I was rubbing my hands.
And Starter Villain by John Scalzi began strongly. Our protagonist, trying to secure a loan to buy a bar with less collateral than that tramp who used to climb trees to stop motorways, learns of his rich uncle’s demise. The dead man’s assistant arrives to tell him that, if he marshals the memorial, in return he’ll inherit enough that he won’t need that loan. At the service, a parade of enemies turns up to try to re-murder the corpse to make sure he’s definitely dead this time. So far so amusing. Well written, enjoyable, up my street.
And then the typing cat turns up.
There’s no creative endeavour that can’t be ruined by a bellend gurning, because we are in the age of idiocy as humour. In this case, the uncle was some kind of supervillain inventor who’d decided that, to get one up on his evil competitors, he needed to push evolution forward a few centuries by creating cats that can somehow hit a space bar without wanting to claw it to buggery or eat it. Our hero’s cat has been watching him and reporting back to the boss. When this cat describes a recently acquired kitten as ‘my intern’, well, I now need some paint for the bedroom wall and a new Kindle.
I’m willing to grudgingly accept that not everybody has the same sense of humour. That said, clever word play, jokes that make sense, events that are objectively entertaining, like a drunk falling into a canal – these, it’s fairly well accepted, fall under the banner of ‘funny’. But so much humour drifts off into the realm of daftness I’m starting to wonder if people are so petrified by the looming prospect of World War 3 they’ve decided we might as well suspend reality by giving the nuclear codes to those two cunts from The Mighty Boosh.
If it was just a popular niche I’d have no issue – there is a place in this world for The Young Ones and Mr Bean – but it’s bloody everywhere. No sitcom these days can get by without an idiot who dances gaily into the kind of situation that would absolutely get him punched in the face in any real life setting. Oh look Jeffrey’s bought a tiny Smart Car to stop global warming, but he’s taken the seat out to give himself more legroom and it means he can’t see over the steering wheel, haha, oh dear he’s accidentally run over that huge bald man’s foot hahaha oh Jeffrey you wag, oh, oh wait, Jeffrey’s getting his face kicked in outside a betting shop. At which, admittedly, I would laugh.
Take world-beating new comedy The Residence. Its main character is an eccentric sleuth who investigates a murder at the White House while wearing a pair of birdwatching binoculars. Even the detective’s name is designed to infantilise the audience: Cordelia Cupp. Are you having a fucking laugh? That makes one of us.
There’s also ‘critically acclaimed’ new series The Studio. In the second episode the main character, a newly promoted Hollywood studio head, goes to watch an incredibly expensive one-shot scene being filmed and he’s very excited about it. He then talks inanely all through filming, doesn’t like his own suit so takes a crucial shirt from the studio wardrobe and parks his car somewhere that fucks up the getaway. In the Hollywood of the grown-up he would be instantly fired and sued for millions, yet there are eight more episodes of this bollocks. I will have to live without the episode where he finances a remake of Schindler’s List and only casts Muslims for inclusiveness, or gets caught short during a read-through while wearing night-vision goggles and an aqualung and pisses all over Meryl Streep.
Everything must be absurd or aimed at the ignoramus. I’ve been accused of having too limited an imagination to find this nonsense funny, or of not having a sharp enough sense of humour to understand it. My counter is that I could shit better comedy with a pencil up my arse. Take this sentence:
The woman walked to the shop to buy some bread.
Some funny yet plausible things could happen to the woman while she did that, like, I don’t know, a man going the other way yawns, a fly goes in his mouth, he chokes and stumbles balls-first into a Lime bike. But stuff that sentence into an AI surreal comedy generator and watch it Matt Berry the fuck out of it:
The blue tit cycled to the abattoir to retrieve his netball.
The astronaut floated to the garden centre to placate some petunias.
Claudia Winkelman teleported to Pentonville to cook some pork chops.
And a sub-section of society would find that funny. These people live among us even now. The collective noun is ‘fuckwits’.
Back in the day I used to enjoy Shooting Stars, the nonsense gameshow with Vic Reeves and Bob Mortimer, but it’s very much the exception that proves the rule. Watch clips of it now, I dare you. Try not to cringe at Reeves’ club singer, “eranu/uvavu” and the Dove from Above. It’s a shambles and we should all be ashamed. Will Self turned to methomania, Ulrika-ka-ka shagged the England manager and nobody’s seen Mark Lamarr since.
People really could get away with anything in the 90s but it’s not the fucking 90s any more. The definition of surreal humour is “a form of humour predicated on deliberate violations of causal reasoning”. Violations is the key word there. If anyone ever successfully makes me endure a Wes Anderson film, you’d better believe there will be violations.
But wait: Monty Python! Yeah yeah, geniuses for sure. But while the films are silly, their scripts are incredibly tight and there’s a plot behind each. The TV series though, Christ alive, it’s shockingly bad. People can name maybe three of the more memorable sketches and the rest is a morass of nude organists, people with names like Raymond Luxury-Yacht and giant animated feet. John Cleese’s best work is Fawlty Towers, Michael Palin’s is travel documentaries, Eric Idle’s is divorces and Terry Gilliam is American so nobody gives a shit. The other two are better off out of it.
And you should see the adverts I get for live comedy these days. Stand-up comedians who rage at the state of the species are gradually being replaced by wistful comics with tales of how they once built a sandcastle and imagined what it would be like to live in, while I imagine the sea surging over the battlements and crushing its inhabitants against sacks of grain. My next trip to the Soho Theatre is a toss-up between a man in a party hat sitting in a dustbin advertising a show called ‘The Day I Got The Horn’ and two people each putting a hand in the other’s mouth performing ’50 Ways To Kill A Slug’. No wait, a late contender: ‘Lachlan Werner: WonderTwunk’.
Silly comedy straddles a fine line, but it’s very clear upon which side of that line you’ll find Father Ted and which Mrs Brown. Everyday situations can be bent very slightly and turned into hilarity; witness One Foot in the Grave. They can also be turned into rage-inducing nonsense, wherein Stath Lets Flats IN HELL.
I’m begging for a few decent writers to return us to those magical times when Malcolm Tucker first burst onto our screens in all-too-plausible fashion. I would write a sitcom myself, but the one and only time I tried to do that (I took a course and everything) what came out was something involving two siblings who run a struggling crazy golf course and I had to actually print it out just so I could burn it.
So yes, I know it’s not easy to write good comedy. But it’s easy to write bad comedy. These are, the internet tells me, the opening lines of the very first episode of the show that epitomises this heinous trend, Toast of London:
“I thought you said you were a bee keeper.”
“No, a beak keeper. I keep beaks.”
“It’s an impressive collection.”
“I didn’t ask you back to my flat to look at my beaks.”
“Of course you didn’t.”
And if that makes you laugh you might as well just take the nuclear codes yourself.